Facebook is opening up the walled garden and sharing…or are they?
“Today we are announcing Facebook Connect. Facebook Connect is the next iteration of Facebook Platform that allows users to “connect” their Facebook identity, friends and privacy to any site. This will now enable third party websites to implement and offer even more features of Facebook Platform off of Facebook – similar to features available to third party applications today on Facebook.”
At a first glance, it might seem as if this is a great move for Facebook and its users. But is it really?
Some initial thoughts.
In an attempt to be the social network across the internet:
- Users can have one web identity (see sxip) which will eliminate the need for the thousands of logins we have.
- Facebook will become even more centralized and necessary for warehousing user information. (Federal Reserve : Money :: Facebook : User Data)
- Third party developers can build much more powerful applications without the restraints of the Facebook platform. No canvas page.
- What was first an attempt to build a platform or centralized location, has now become an open initiative, encouraging users to engage third party websites ultimately leaving them with less advertising inventory.
- User data might now become available for third party ad targeting outside of Facebook.com
- Disrupting their own Facebook App ecosystem
- New revenue model? Their current one isn’t really working.
- They are becoming more open
- They are becoming more closed
“As Kaliya stated, I’m afraid that this is just another strategy for Facebook to “lock-in” their users and attempt to become the central repository of everyone’s social graph. If that’s the case, this is not data portability as I still don’t have full control over my data.
Hopefully, they’re going to be fully supporting open standards, but I doubt it. Facebook strikes me as a company that pretends to be open, but is only open one-way or to the extent that they can control.
Facebook is Microsoft 2.0”
Looks like we will have to wait and see, but something tells me Ryan and Kaliya will be right.